how likely is it that new 52 aquaman can defeat homelander

New 52 Aquaman is more likely to beat Homelander than the other way around. In a straight fight, I’d lean Aquaman wins most of the time , especially if water is involved; on dry land with no prep, it gets closer, but Homelander still looks outmatched in versatility and combat skill.

Why Aquaman has the edge

• New 52 Aquaman is portrayed as a top-tier Atlantean warrior with very high strength, durability, and combat training, plus the trident and water-based advantages.

• Community matchup discussions commonly frame Aquaman as a strong favorite because Homelander’s raw aggression and flight are dangerous, but not always enough against Aquaman’s broader toolkit.

• Water is the big swing factor: Aquaman’s power, mobility, and battlefield control improve dramatically near the ocean or in flooded environments.

Homelander’s win path

• Homelander can still win if he keeps the fight in the air, attacks from range, and avoids letting Aquaman close the distance.

• His heat vision and flight give him a real opening against opponents who rely on melee range, and some fan analyses argue that speed and aerial pressure could let him dominate early.

• If Aquaman is isolated on open land and never gets a clean hit, Homelander’s odds improve a lot.

Likely outcome

For New 52 Aquaman vs Homelander , I’d call it:

1. Aquaman wins about 6–7 times out of 10 in a neutral fight.

2. Aquaman wins even more often near water.

3. Homelander’s best shot is a fast aerial blitz before Aquaman adapts.

Verdict

If this is the New 52 version specifically, Aquaman is the safer pick because he has the stronger overall combat profile and better answers to Homelander’s offense. Homelander can absolutely make it ugly, but he usually needs ideal conditions to pull off the upset.

TL;DR: Aquaman likely wins, especially near water; Homelander only takes it reliably if he controls the pace and never lets Aquaman fight on his terms.