which is higher rated Ollie or The farmer's dog

The Farmer’s Dog appears to be more highly rated overall than Ollie based on recent roundup coverage and search visibility, though both are considered top fresh dog food brands. A 2026 comparison piece and other recent reviews frame The Farmer’s Dog as the more popular option, while Ollie is still a strong contender.

Quick read

• The Farmer’s Dog: tends to rank a little higher in recent comparisons and appears to lead in market interest.

• Ollie: well-reviewed, premium fresh food, but usually positioned just behind The Farmer’s Dog in direct comparisons.
• Best choice overall: if you mean “higher rated” in mainstream review coverage, The Farmer’s Dog has the edge.

Why that’s the trend

Recent articles comparing the two consistently describe them as the two biggest names in fresh dog food, but The Farmer’s Dog is more often framed as the stronger pick overall. Search/traffic data also suggests it leads the category in consumer interest.

Practical difference

• Choose The Farmer’s Dog if you want the more broadly recognized option and the one that most recent coverage favors.

• Choose Ollie if you want a very similar fresh-food subscription and find a better fit on recipe variety, price, or your dog’s preferences.

Bottom line

For a simple answer: The Farmer’s Dog is generally higher rated than Ollie right now. Ollie is still highly regarded, but it usually comes second in head-to-head coverage. TL;DR: The Farmer’s Dog wins on overall rating and popularity, while Ollie remains a strong runner-up.