which region in rdr2 woyld you live in

I’d live in Big Valley , probably near Strawberry or the quieter ranch land. It’s the best mix of scenic, peaceful, and practical, while still feeling like the kind of place you could actually survive in RDR2.

Why that region

• Beautiful setting. Big Valley gets mentioned a lot because it feels calmer and more livable than the rougher towns.

• Less chaos. Compared with places like Valentine or the more dangerous frontier spots, it seems like a safer long-term choice.

• Good balance. You get nature, open space, and access to town without being stuck in the middle of constant trouble.

Other strong picks

• Saint Denis if you want the safest, most urban option, since players often point to it as the safest city.

• Blackwater area if you want something more settled and comfortable.

• Cumberland Forest if you prefer a quieter, wooded life.

My pick in one line

If I had to choose one region, Big Valley wins because it looks like the best place to live, not just the coolest place to visit.

Would you pick a peaceful spot like Big Valley, or a city like Saint Denis?