who was the other girl up for hannah montana

The “other girl” up for Hannah Montana alongside Miley Cyrus was not just one person – there were a few key finalists, but two names are most often cited as the main alternatives.

Direct answer

Casting director Lisa London has said that the top three finalists for the lead role were: Taylor Momsen, Daniella Monet, and Miley Cyrus, with Cyrus ultimately getting the part.

From that group, the two “runner‑up” actresses most commonly mentioned as the other options for Hannah Montana are:

• Taylor Momsen (later Jenny Humphrey on Gossip Girl).

• Daniella Monet (later Trina on Victorious).

So when people ask “who was the other girl up for Hannah Montana ,” they are usually referring to Taylor Momsen or Daniella Monet , who were in the final three with Miley Cyrus.

Quick Scoop: What actually happened in casting?

• Lisa London, the original casting director, has shown an old casting sheet listing the final three candidates: Miley Cyrus, Taylor Momsen, and Daniella Monet.

• She’s also clarified that Belinda (a rumor that went viral on TikTok) was not in that final top three, even though fans kept repeating it online.

• Over the years, Disney insiders and later interviews have backed up that Miley had to beat out over 1,200 girls before it came down to that very small final group.

In fan discussions and news write‑ups, when they say “the other girl who almost played Hannah Montana” , they’re usually spotlighting Taylor Momsen as the main alternate, with Daniella Monet close behind as another serious contender.

Other famous names who were in the mix

Even beyond those final three, a few other Disney‑verse names come up in interviews and social posts about Hannah Montana casting:

• Aly & AJ (Aly Michalka and AJ Michalka) – AJ has said that Disney’s then‑president originally offered the Hannah role to Aly , with AJ being considered for Lilly Truscott, but it didn’t end up happening.

• AJ Michalka later clarified this on social media, saying they were approached rather than going through the same final‑three test Miley did.

These stories fuel a lot of forum and TikTok gossip, but the most solid, documented “other girls up for Hannah Montana” remain Taylor Momsen and Daniella Monet in that last round with Miley.

Mini timeline reference

1. Early–mid 2000s: Disney holds a huge casting search (over 1,200 girls) for what was then a character named “Chloe Stewart,” later changed to Miley Stewart.

2. Final network tests: Miley Cyrus, Taylor Momsen, and Daniella Monet are the last three testing for the lead.

3. Disney goes with Miley, and the show premieres in 2006, turning her into a breakout star.

TL;DR

If you’re looking for a single name, the most commonly cited “other girl up for Hannah Montana” is Taylor Momsen , with Daniella Monet also confirmed as another finalist in that same last group with Miley Cyrus.

Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.