why does hilary duff not talk to her sister
Hilary Duff and her older sister, Haylie Duff, are currently estranged and do not talk much—if at all—but Hilary has not publicly given one single, clear reason for the silence.
What we know about the rift
- The sisters were once very close and even collaborated musically, but they have not been seen together in public since around 2019 and rarely interact on social media.
- Hilary has acknowledged a “complicated” and “estranged” relationship with Haylie, calling it “family drama” and saying she now feels ready to open up about it through her music.
Possible reasons fans and outlets speculate
- Husbands’ tension : Gossip outlets and fan forums have suggested that friction between Hilary’s husband, Matthew Koma, and Haylie’s partner, Matthew Rosenberg, may have contributed to the distance.
- Political and lifestyle differences : Some fans speculate that Haylie’s more conservative leanings and move to Texas contrast with Hilary’s liberal, Los Angeles–centric lifestyle, adding strain.
- Family history and divorce fallout : Both sisters grew up amid their parents’ messy divorce and long‑running legal issues, which Hilary has said shaped complicated family dynamics.
How Hilary has addressed it
- On her new album, Hilary released a song called “We Don’t Talk,” which appears to be about her estrangement from Haylie, with lyrics questioning when and why they stopped communicating.
- In interviews, she has framed the situation as an “emotional eviction” and emphasized that she can only manage her own side of the relationship, without directly blaming Haylie.
Current status
- As of early 2026, the sisters are still not seen together, and Haylie has not publicly commented on the feud or the song.
- In other words, there is no confirmed, single explanation —only that the relationship has grown distant over time, likely due to a mix of personal, marital, and family‑history factors.
Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.