why was b simone cancelled
B. Simone has faced multiple “cancellation” waves over the years, mostly tied to her book plagiarism scandal, controversial comments, and what many see as inauthentic branding and behavior online.
Why Was B. Simone “Cancelled”?
Main Reasons People Turned On Her
- Plagiarism scandal (the big one)
- Her 2020 book “Baby Girl: Manifest the Life You Want” was accused of lifting material directly from bloggers and Pinterest-style content creators, sometimes almost word-for-word.
* Critics argued this showed disrespect for smaller creators and her core audience, especially Black women who supported her brand.
* Even though she apologized and blamed her team, many felt she dodged full responsibility, which hurt her reputation long-term.
- “9 to 5” comments about men
- In an interview, she said she didn’t want to date a man with a regular “9 to 5” job and preferred an entrepreneur who would understand her lifestyle.
* Many fans with traditional jobs felt insulted, seeing her as elitist and out of touch, especially since her success came largely from everyday people supporting her.
- Perceived inauthenticity and constant rebranding
- Commentators and fans have pointed out a pattern: shifting from crystals/spirituality to heavy Christianity branding, then into different “boss woman” and relationship-guru personas, often very quickly.
* Some media and fans say her transformations since around 2024 feel more like marketing strategies than genuine growth, making people feel like they’re watching a “shape-shifting” act for engagement and profit.
- Monetizing grief and personal drama
- She received backlash for how she publicly grieved her friend Jackie Oh and then folded that attention into monetized “close friends” content and other offerings.
* To critics, it looked like she was using very sensitive moments (death, friendship fallouts) as content and sales funnels, which many found distasteful.
- Friendship fallouts and character questions
- Public fallouts with former close friends (like Megan Ashley) have led some viewers to question her sincerity and how she treats people behind the scenes.
* Posts and discussions often paint her as jealous or competitive, happy for friends only up to the point they don’t surpass her.
- Earlier “cancellation” over activism silence
- During the George Floyd protests, she was criticized for being quiet on social media; some felt she wasn’t doing enough given how much she benefitted from Black audiences.
* Think-piece style commentary at the time framed part of the outrage as “fake outrage,” but it added to the pattern of people feeling disappointed or let down by her.
How The Backlash Affected Her
- Commentators note that after the major controversies, her income reportedly dropped dramatically at one point (from extremely high earnings down to a fraction of that) as fans pulled back support.
- Coverage and case-study videos now frame her as a cautionary tale about brand mismanagement, inauthentic persona shifts, and disrespecting your core audience.
- Articles describe the Black online community, especially Black women, as increasingly “over” her antics and seeing her as a red flag rather than an aspirational figure.
Is She Fully “Cancelled” Or Just Controversial?
- She still has followers, a platform, and ongoing projects, so she isn’t “gone,” but her image is much more polarizing now.
- For some, the plagiarism scandal was the unforgivable line; for others, it’s the repeated pattern of perceived clout-chasing, poor accountability, and monetizing vulnerable moments.
- There are also people who feel cancel culture went too far and believe she is trying to evolve, even if clumsily; they point to her apologies and attempts to pivot as evidence she’s learning, not just scheming.
Quick HTML Table of Key Controversies
| Issue | What Happened | Why People Were Mad |
|---|---|---|
| Book plagiarism | Accused of copying content from small creators for her book “Baby Girl: Manifest the Life You Want.” | [9][7]Seen as exploiting smaller creators and her own fan base, with weak accountability. | [7][5]
| “9 to 5” comments | Said she didn’t want to date a man with a regular 9–5 job, preferring an entrepreneur. | [7]Viewed as elitist and disrespectful to working-class supporters. | [3][1]
| Rebranding & faith pivots | Rapid shifts between spiritual personas (crystals, Christianity, “boss babe,” etc.). | [1][3][5]Felt like calculated marketing, not genuine evolution. | [3][1]
| Monetizing grief | Public grieving of Jackie Oh allegedly tied into paid “close friends” content and branding. | [3][5]Seen as exploiting tragedy for clicks and money. | [5][3]
| Friendship fallouts | Public tensions and breakups with close friends like Megan Ashley. | [10][3][5]Added to perception she is jealous, self-focused, and not the supportive friend she brands herself as. | [5]
| Activism criticism | Called out for perceived silence/weak activism around George Floyd era protests. | [4][8]Some felt she owed more visible support to the same community that elevated her. | [8][4]
Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.