"Are We Dating the Same Guy?" refers to a network of women-only Facebook groups where members anonymously share dating app screenshots and experiences to warn others about potentially risky men. These groups exploded in popularity around 2022-2023, amassing millions of members worldwide by early 2024.

Core Concept

The platform started as city-specific Facebook groups (e.g., "Are We Dating the Same Guy - New York") where women post a guy's profile pic, name, and details, then ask for "tea" or insights like "any red flags?" Others chime in with stories of ghosting, cheating, or worse. Moderators keep it women-only to foster safety, but drama often brews from unverified claims.

"Here’s his profile pic (he looks so charming while smoking from that bong!). He claims to be self-employed... Are there any warning signs?"

Trending Buzz and Controversies

By January 2026, these groups remain a hot topic on Reddit and TikTok, with over 8 million members across 200+ cities. Recent forum chatter highlights lawsuits from men claiming defamation, privacy invasions, and doxxing—some groups got banned or went private. Feminists hail it as empowerment against predatory dating, while critics call it vigilante mob justice.

  • Pros shared in discussions : Validates experiences, spots serial daters, builds community support.
  • Cons trending now : False accusations ruin lives, men feel hunted, lacks due process.

Alternative sites like arewedatingthesame.com popped up as "fair" platforms for both genders to browse profiles and comment anonymously, ditching Facebook's biases.

How It Works in Practice

  1. Join your city's group (must prove you're female via vetting).
  2. Post a guy's deets from Tinder/Bumble/Hinge.
  3. Community responds with stories—expect heated debates on everything from "he's a liar" to "great guy, run with that doubt."

One viral 2025 Reddit thread dissected a post: User shared a "self-employed" guy's pic, got warnings about no-car excuses and sketchy vibes—classic red- flag roundup.

Men's Side and Alternatives

Guys launched counter-sites like arewedatingthesameguy.com (for women) and guy-focused versions, pushing back with "fairness for all." These let users add profiles, read reviews, and search cities without Facebook drama. As of late 2025, they're gaining traction amid backlash against the originals.

TL;DR : A viral forum for dating intel that's equal parts helpful and chaotic—latest news shows legal fights and gender-balanced clones rising.

Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.