I Can Only Imagine 2 is a 2026 Christian biographical drama and brings back most of the key faces from the original, along with several new ones in central roles.

Main cast (core characters)

  • John Michael Finley as Bart Millard , lead singer of MercyMe, now navigating fame, family, and faith after the success of “I Can Only Imagine.”
  • Milo Ventimiglia as Tim Timmons , a hopeful newcomer joining the tour as Bart’s warm-up act and eventual friend, carrying struggles of his own.
  • Sophie Skelton as Shannon (Shannon Street) Millard , Bart’s wife, trying to hold their family together as touring pressures rise.
  • Arielle Kebbel as Hilary Timmons , Tim’s wife, who helps reveal more of Tim’s backstory and burdens.
  • Sammy Dell as Sam Millard , Bart and Shannon’s son, whose fragile relationship with Bart is central to the sequel’s emotional stakes.
  • Trace Adkins as Scott Brickell , MercyMe’s longtime manager, again trying to balance ministry, business, and band tensions.
  • Dennis Quaid as Arthur Millard , Bart’s late but redeemed father, appearing in memories/flashbacks and continuing the father–son theme from the first film.

Notable supporting cast

  • Anjelah Johnson-Reyes as Dr. Ramirez , connected to the family’s emotional and possibly medical journey.
  • Joshua Bassett as Christopher , a new character tied into Bart and Tim’s story on the tour.
  • Jason Burkey as Mike , returning in the band’s wider circle.
  • Abby Glover as Ally Hastings , part of the extended relational network in Bart’s world.
  • Jobie James as Musician , among several characters around the touring life.

Quick HTML table of key cast

[6][7][1][3] [7][1][6][3] [1][3] [1][5][3] [6][1][3] [7][1][5][3] [7][1][5][3] [5][3] [3][5] [5][3]
Actor Role Notes
John Michael Finley Bart Millard Lead singer of MercyMe, central protagonist.
Milo Ventimiglia Tim Timmons Newcomer artist joining the tour, key new lead.
Sophie Skelton Shannon Millard Bart’s wife, now played by Skelton instead of Madeline Carroll.
Arielle Kebbel Hilary Timmons Tim’s wife, part of the new family dynamic.
Sammy Dell Sam Millard Bart and Shannon’s son, key emotional focus.
Trace Adkins Scott Brickell MercyMe’s manager, returning from the first film.
Dennis Quaid Arthur Millard Bart’s late father, seen in flashbacks and memory.
Anjelah Johnson-Reyes Dr. Ramirez New supporting character in Bart’s circle.
Joshua Bassett Christopher New character connected to the tour storyline.
Jason Burkey Mike Supporting role around the band and tour.

Story & current status (as of early 2026)

  • The film follows Bart after “I Can Only Imagine” as he juggles sold‑out arenas, a devoted fan base, and the strain that success puts on his marriage and relationship with his son, Sam.
  • Tim Timmons’ arrival on the tour becomes a catalyst, forcing Bart to revisit his past and face what fame is costing his family.
  • It is scheduled for theatrical release in the U.S. on February 20, 2026, with some international releases (like Australia and New Zealand) in early March 2026.

Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.