Colton Underwood's Traitors Journey: Unmasking Suspects and Facing Backlash Colton Underwood, the former Bachelor star, played an aggressive role as a Faithful in The Traitors US Season 4, aggressively pushing theories on who the Traitors were before his shocking elimination. He suspected players like Candiace Dillard Bassett based on voting patterns and "throwaway votes," sharing these hunches with ally Rob Rausch—who turned out to be a Traitor himself. In post-elimination interviews, Colton praised Rob's strategy of letting Candiace "dig her own grave" by withholding info, which led to her banishment right after his own murder in the castle.

Key Moments of Colton's "Detective" Phase

Colton's hunt for Traitors ramped up mid-season, creating high-stakes drama that fans are still buzzing about on forums like Reddit:

  • Early Suspicions : After Tiffany Mitchell's turret exit naming wrong Traitors, Colton targeted her allies, convincing others like Johnny Weir he was onto something—only for it to backfire as Faithfuls turned on him.
  • Roundtable Heat : Michael Rapaport called him out as "conniving, colluding Colton," sparking debates if it referenced his gameplay or personal life; Colton felt it crossed into his sexuality, rallying sympathy.
  • Final Betrayal : He confided Candiace suspicions to Rob, unaware Rob was a Traitor who handed the dagger to her, making her eliminate the wrong person (Colton) and expose herself. Colton later called it "the best move of the game."

Fans on Reddit dissected his tactics relentlessly:

"It makes me wonder if he truly considers her a traitor, because if he did, he’d be acting foolishly—since if both of them survived to the end, she would receive the money while he would be left empty-handed."

Forum Buzz and Trending Backlash

Online discussions exploded around Colton's "smug" vibe and U-turns, like initially skipping the reunion over a "villain edit" before reconsidering amid Lisa Rinna drama—she labeled him a "stalker" online, fueling TikTok pile-ons. Reddit threads like "Uhhh…Colton" and "What exactly was Colton trying to accomplish?" trended, with users speculating he prioritized spotlight over strategy: "Colton prioritizes being the focal point over securing victory."

Cyberbullying Fallout : Colton's outspoken plays led to death threats against him and his family, prompting a cast-wide statement against harassment. He addressed it head-on: "That's crossing the line... It's not OK," while defending his game and denying he knew Rob's secret. Rob Funches also spoke out, tying into broader cast support. As of early February 2026, reunion hype is building, with Colton eyeing a Rinna confrontation.

Player| Colton's Main Suspicion| Outcome
---|---|---
Candiace Dillard Bassett| Throwaway votes & strategy| Banished post-Colton 2
Tiffany Mitchell| Turret tactics| Already out, wrong names 4
Rob Rausch| Trusted ally (revealed Traitor)| Masterminded Colton's exit 6
Lisa Rinna| Tense dynamic| Offline feud escalated 8

This saga highlights The Traitors' mix of strategy and personal beefs, keeping Season 4 a trending topic into 2026—perfect for reality TV diehards debating Colton's bold traitor hunt.

TL;DR : Colton aggressively sniffed out Traitors like Candiace (correctly, indirectly) but got blindsided by ally Rob; his gameplay sparked threats, forum wars, and reunion drama.

Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.