Guardian's Take on Melania The Guardian has published critical reviews of recent Melania Trump projects, particularly focusing on a new Amazon-backed documentary titled Melania. Released just days ago amid her role as First Lady during President Donald Trump's second term, the film drew sharp backlash for its perceived lack of depth and self-promotional tone.

Documentary Critique

In a January 31, 2026, piece, The Guardian dismissed the documentary as a "listless vanity project," highlighting its failure to engage viewers despite following Melania in the 20 days before her husband's January 2025 inauguration. Critics noted it portrays her as a "preening, scowling void of pure nothingness," echoing broader sentiments of it being "ghastly propaganda" rather than insightful journalism. This aligns with earlier Guardian coverage from August 2025, which explored Melania's growing influence on Trump—such as shifts on Gaza aid and Putin skepticism—while questioning her limited White House presence and political detachment.

"The fun's not infectious and the guests are a nightmare, and two hours of Melania feels like pure, endless hell."

Book Memoir Reactions

The Guardian also covered Melania's 2024 memoir Melania , framing it as a "blame-dodging masterclass." Forum discussions amplified this, mocking its 180 pages (plus 64 photo pages) for evasive takes on controversies like her "I really don't care, do you?" jacket during the family separation policy. Readers on Reddit called the writing simplistic, like "ChatGPT" or a "middle school report," with no real reckoning for leaked tapes defending border practices.

Forum Buzz & Trending Views

  • Reddit Threads (/r/Fauxmoi, /r/Qult_Headquarters) : Users roasted the memoir for glossing over Christmas decor complaints and Trump's communication style, with one quip: "Melania: Or how I thought he would be dead by now." Upvotes hit 337+ on blame-dodging takes.
  • Multiple Perspectives : Supporters see her as an independent voice influencing Trump on issues like abortion rights and child welfare (e.g., Be Best campaign). Detractors view projects as gilded PR, remaking her image from Slovenia model to power player.
  • Instagram/Standard.co.uk Echo : Even milder reviews note she's "not Princess Di but wants us to know she cares," tying into her Africa trips and USAID pride.

Influence in Trump's Term

As of January 2026, six months into Trump's reelected presidency, Melania's sway remains a hot topic. British officials eye her for decoding Trump's Gaza volte-face (crediting her humanitarian concerns) and Ukraine peace comments. Yet actions lag—aid claims disputed, no policy overhauls—fueling speculation she's more neutral advisor than active First Lady.

This buzz fits celebrity gossip trends, with her memoir hitting #1 NYT but Goodreads reviews skewing savage (e.g., "laugh your arse off for all the wrong reasons"). No full Guardian book review surfaced, but their pattern critiques her elusive persona amid 2025-2026 scrutiny.

TL;DR : Guardian slams the Melania doc as vanity fluff; memoir seen as evasive in forums. Her subtle Trump influence persists, but projects underwhelm critics.

Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.