Prathichaya is getting mostly mixed-to-negative reviews overall, with a few viewers appreciating the performances and political theme, but many critics calling out the predictable writing, slow pacing, and uneven execution.

Quick Scoop

The broad take seems to be:

  • What works: Nivin Pauly’s restrained performance, the political backdrop, and some topical ideas.
  • What doesn’t: Dated storytelling, weak script, uneven performances, and a lack of freshness in the thriller format.
  • Audience vibe: Some public reactions describe it as a one-time watch or a film with mixed feelings rather than a clear hit.

Review Snapshot

Source| Overall take
---|---
Rotten Tomatoes| Timely ideas, but weighed down by predictable plotting and dated storytelling 5
Nowrunning| Familiar political drama that struggles to rise above predictability 8
NDTV| Slow-paced, underwhelming script, but Nivin Pauly’s performance helps 9
IMDb snippet| “Balanced masala film,” “one-time watch” 6
Reddit discussion| Mixed feelings from viewers 1

Common Praise

  • Nivin Pauly’s performance is getting some appreciation for being more restrained and mature.
  • The movie’s political and moral themes are seen as relevant, even if the execution is uneven.
  • Some viewers feel it has enough moments to make it a decent watch if you like political dramas.

Common Criticism

  • The story is often described as predictable and old-fashioned.
  • Several reviews mention weak writing and slow pacing.
  • A few critics also point to uneven sound/design and a lack of real tension.

Bottom Line

If you like political dramas and don’t mind a slow build, Prathichaya may still interest you, mainly for the performances. If you want a sharp, fresh thriller, the reviews suggest it may feel conventional and underwhelming.

If you want, I can also give you:

  1. a spoiler-free verdict , or
  2. a Malayalam-language review summary.