Scott Thomas, known from Love Island , has appeared on two main series of the UK version: the original second season in 2016 and Love Island: All Stars Series 2 in 2025.

Meanwhile, Scott van-der-Sluis holds the record with three appearances across Love Island variants in recent years, including the main UK show, Love Island Games , and All Stars Series 3 in 2026.

Scott Thomas Breakdown

  • 2016 (Series 2) : Entered as an original Islander, coupled with Kady McDermott, reached the final in 3rd place.
  • 2025 (All Stars Series 2) : Returned after nearly a decade, left voluntarily after a dramatic run with challenges like the Kissing Challenge.

Scott van-der-Sluis Breakdown

This former goalkeeper racked up appearances rapidly:

  1. Main UK Love Island (eliminated after one week).
  2. Love Island Games (dumped after three days).
  3. All Stars Series 3 (entered Day 1 as bombshell in 2026).

TL;DR : If referring to OG Scott Thomas, it's two Love Islands; for the quick-fire Scott van-der-Sluis, it's three.

Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.