Witney Carson has won two Mirrorball Trophies on Dancing with the Stars. Her first victory came in Season 19 with partner Alfonso Ribeiro in 2014, marking her as one of the few pros to win early in her career. She recently claimed her second in Season 34 alongside Robert Irwin.

First Win Details

Witney Carson, at just 21, triumphed in Season 19 after joining DWTS as a pro dancer. Paired with actor Alfonso Ribeiro, their chemistry and routines secured the Len Goodman Mirrorball Trophy on November 25, 2014. This win highlighted her rapid rise, as noted in fan discussions celebrating the full- circle moment a decade later.

Second Win Triumph

In the high-stakes Season 34 finale on November 25, 2025, Carson and wildlife conservationist Robert Irwin clinched victory amid fierce competition from finalists like Alix Earle and Dylan Efron. Judges awarded perfect scores in key rounds, boosted by over 72 million viewer votes, in one of DWTS's tightest seasons. Carson called Irwin her "win already" as a friend, echoing emotional family support in the audience.

Fan and Forum Buzz

Reddit threads praise Carson's deserving second Mirrorball, noting her dance prowess despite past popularity challenges. Fans on Facebook and Instagram draw parallels to her age-21 first win, with Robert Irwin matching that at 21 for Season 34—pure poetic symmetry. Alfonso Ribeiro's presence to present the trophy added nostalgic flair, thrilling longtime viewers.

Trending Context

As of January 2026, Season 34 remains a hot topic, with Carson's back-to-back milestone sparking "two Mirrorballs now" posts from Bindi Irwin. Forums speculate on her future pairings, blending gossip with admiration for her 11-year journey.

TL;DR: Two Mirrorballs total—Season 19 (2014, Alfonso Ribeiro) and Season 34 (2025, Robert Irwin).

Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.