There are currently two notable “Will Smith” players associated with MLB: one active and one veteran who most recently played in 2023.

Current Will Smiths in (or tied to) MLB

  • Will Smith (catcher) – Active catcher for the Los Angeles Dodgers, an All‑Star and multi–World Series champion.
  • Will Smith (pitcher) – Veteran left‑handed reliever who has pitched for several teams (Royals, Brewers, Giants, Braves, Astros, Rangers) and is currently a free agent, but is still a recent MLB player and often counted in “how many Will Smiths” conversations.

So if the question is “how many Will Smiths are in the MLB” in the loose, fan‑discussion sense, people usually talk about two MLB Will Smiths : the Dodgers catcher and the lefty reliever.

Quick Scoop: Why This Became a Thing

  • The Dodgers catcher has become one of the best offensive catchers in baseball, starring in multiple postseason runs and World Series wins, which keeps his name constantly in the spotlight.
  • The reliever pulled off the rare feat of winning three straight World Series titles with three different teams (Braves 2021, Astros 2022, Rangers 2023), turning “Will Smith” into a running joke every October.

Because both were good and relevant at the same time, “how many Will Smiths are in MLB?” turned into a fun recurring forum and broadcast line.

TL;DR: Fans usually mean the Dodgers catcher and the veteran lefty reliever, so the practical answer is two MLB Will Smiths in recent memory.

Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.