The best public estimate for a small strawberry milkshake at McDonald’s in Penfield is about $4.79–$3.99 , but I’d treat that as approximate because the exact store price can vary by location and ordering channel. A Penfield- specific price tracker I found lists the medium strawberry shake at $5.99 , which suggests the small would likely be a bit lower at that location.

What I found

  • McDonald’s’ own product page confirms the small strawberry shake exists and notes that delivery prices may be higher than in-store prices.
  • One 2026 menu tracker shows Penfield’s medium strawberry shake at $5.99.
  • Other current menu lists show small strawberry shakes around $3.99 to $4.79 depending on market.

Practical answer

If you’re ordering in Penfield, a reasonable expectation is around $4 to $5 , with the exact total depending on the restaurant, taxes, and whether you order in person, in-app, or through delivery.

Quick note

The fastest way to get the exact local price is usually the McDonald’s app or the restaurant’s ordering screen, since those reflect the store’s current menu pricing.