Arthur Morgan is portrayed as well beyond real‑world human strength, sitting in the “peak human verging on low‑level superhuman” range by game logic and fan analysis. He routinely performs feats that would seriously injure or kill an average person, even before factoring in his illness later in the story.

Physical Feats In-Game

  • Arthur can fistfight and kill or incapacitate bears, wolves, and cougars, sometimes finishing them off with his bare hands.
  • He restrains large animals such as bison and elk with a lasso and brute force, something far beyond normal cowboy capability.
  • He carries large game (like rams estimated at 300+ lb) on his shoulders and can still move at a jog, showing very high functional strength.

Combat Strength And Durability

  • Arthur can knock grown men out with a single punch and send them flying back several feet in scripted and unscripted fights.
  • In the bar fight with Tommy, he beats a man much larger than himself badly enough to leave a dent in Tommy’s skull, often cited as one of his biggest strength showings.
  • He can break a human neck with his hands, an act often estimated in fan discussions to need roughly 1,000–1,250 ft‑lb of force.

“Stats” And Fan Estimates

  • Fans who translate feats into gym numbers often place Arthur around a 350–405 lb bench press, 500+ lb squat, and 600+ lb deadlift at his heaviest, acknowledging this is extrapolation from gameplay, not canon stats.
  • Even when wounded by multiple gunshots, Arthur can still sprint, brawl, and function as if only lightly injured, which is clearly beyond realistic human durability and more in line with game‑mechanic “superhuman.”
  • Community threads often summarize him as “above your average man” to a significant degree: top‑tier strongman by real‑world standards, but not on the level of comic‑book superheroes.

Context In The Story

  • The narrative still grounds Arthur in a rough realism: his strength doesn’t protect him from disease, aging, or the consequences of his lifestyle, which is why many players see his physical power contrasted with his ultimate vulnerability.
  • In forums and video essays, people highlight that his toughness serves the story thematically: a man strong enough to survive almost anything external, but ultimately fighting an internal battle he cannot win.

TL;DR: In “how strong is Arthur Morgan” terms, he’s a peak human powerhouse who can manhandle wild animals, crush opponents in fistfights, and tank absurd damage, putting him well above realistic cowboys and closer to low‑tier superhuman by fan standards.

Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.