Direct answer: In current Terraria there is no item named "Chester's Arrow" in the official game, so there is no official crafting recipe to make one.

Quick details

  • The Terraria wiki lists all arrow types and their crafting or drop sources; "Chester's Arrow" does not appear on that list, indicating it isn't an official arrow type.
  • Common arrow types and how you make them (examples): Wooden Arrows from wood + stone at a Work Bench, Flaming Arrows from wooden arrows + torches, and Jester's Arrows from wooden arrows + Fallen Stars; these are representative of how arrow crafting generally works in Terraria.

Why you might have heard the name

  • User-created mods, texture packs, or server plugins often add custom items with unique names (for example, named after players or forum characters like "Chester"), so "Chester's Arrow" is likely from a mod or community server rather than vanilla Terraria.
  • Forum posts and video guides frequently showcase modded arrows and custom recipes; searching mod pages or the server/forum where you saw the name will often find the recipe.

If you want the recipe (next steps)

  1. Tell me where you saw "Chester's Arrow" (mod name, server, video, or forum). If it’s from a specific mod or server, I can search for that mod's documentation or common mod repositories to find the recipe.
  2. If you want a vanilla-equivalent suggestion, I can propose a balanced recipe (materials and crafting station) that fits Terraria's progression and stats, and explain how to implement it if you run a server or mod (safe, non-copyright guidance).

Example vanilla-style recipe suggestion (if you want to use it on a mod/server)

  • Pre-Hardmode idea: 50 Wooden Arrows + 5 Fallen Stars + Work Bench -> 50 Chester's Arrows (piercing + small light emission). This mirrors how Jester's / Flaming arrows scale. (This is a suggested homebrew recipe — not official.)

If you'd like, I can:

  • Search the mod repositories and forum threads where the name appears if you give the mod/server name or a link.
  • Provide step-by-step instructions to add a custom arrow (with recipe and stats) to a tModLoader mod or a server plugin, including example code snippets.

Short closing note
"Chester's Arrow" isn't in official Terraria content, so to get its recipe we need the mod/server source or to create a homebrew recipe; tell me where you saw it or whether you want an official-style custom recipe and I’ll continue.

Bottom note: Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.