You turn off Smart Sell on Poshmark from each individual listing’s edit flow; there is no true “master” off switch for your whole closet right now, based on seller reports and Poshmark’s own explanations of the feature.

What Smart Sell Does

  • Smart Sell automatically accepts or counters offers down to a minimum price you set, so buyers can get instant responses without you manually replying.
  • Newer listings often have Smart Sell toggled on by default, while older listings may have it off unless you manually enabled it.

How to Turn Off Smart Sell (Per Listing)

On the app, sellers consistently describe a similar pattern:

  1. Open the listing where you want Smart Sell off.
  1. Tap Edit listing (or start editing as if you’re changing something).
  1. Tap Next or continue to the next screen (often upper-right) instead of saving immediately.
  1. On the following screen, look for the Smart Sell section or toggle within the listing details/share/offer settings.
  1. Toggle Smart Sell off for that item, then complete the edit—finish updating or relisting so the change actually saves.

Many sellers note that if you back out before fully finishing the edit flow (for example, not tapping the final update/relist), Smart Sell can appear to stay on or re-activate.

Why It Feels “Stuck” or Won’t Stay Off

  • Some users say Smart Sell shows as off when editing, but the listing still behaves like it’s on or blocks sending manual offers until the Smart Sell offer is declined or cleared.
  • Others report that they must:
    • Turn it off in edit,
    • Make sure there is no active Smart Sell offer (decline/let it expire),
    • Then complete the edit and sometimes even restart the app to see the change.

If Smart Sell still appears active:

  • Decline any open Smart Sell offer tied to that listing first.
  • Fully close and reopen the app, or uninstall/reinstall if it seems glitchy, as some sellers say a fresh app session helped the toggle “stick.”

Can You Turn Off Smart Sell for All Listings?

  • Multiple sellers specifically complain that there is no bulk/global Smart Sell off switch , meaning you must go listing by listing to disable it.
  • Advice from regular resellers is to:
    • Make sure the Smart Sell toggle is off before you publish new listings.
* Then, slowly work through older listings when you have time, toggling it off individually.

Quick Troubleshooting Checklist

  • Can’t send offers because Smart Sell is “in charge”?
    • Check for an active Smart Sell offer and decline it first.
  • Toggle looks off but behavior says it’s on:
    • Re‑edit the listing, go to the Smart Sell section via Next/update screens, confirm it’s off, and save again.
  • App acting buggy:
    • Restart phone or tablet and/or reinstall the app.

Bottom note: Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.