Quentin Tarantino recently criticized Paul Dano very bluntly, mainly over Dano’s performance in the film There Will Be Blood.

What Tarantino Actually Said

On a podcast where he was listing his favorite films of the 21st century, Tarantino said There Will Be Blood could have ranked higher for him “if it didn’t have a big giant flaw” and then added that “the flaw is Paul Dano.”

He argued that the movie is supposed to be a “two-hander” between Daniel Day‑Lewis and Paul Dano, but that “it’s glaringly obvious that it’s not” because, in his view, Dano cannot stand toe‑to‑toe with Day‑Lewis.

The Harsh Phrases He Used

Tarantino used several very sharp terms about Dano’s acting in that role:

  • He called Dano “weak sauce” and “a weak sister.”
  • He described him as “the weakest male actor in SAG” and “a weak, weak, uninteresting guy.”
  • He said Dano’s work in the film was a “non‑entity performance,” clarifying that he didn’t think it was outright terrible, just that it left no impact for him.

He also suggested that someone like Austin Butler “would have been wonderful in that role,” implying he thinks a stronger foil to Day‑Lewis would have made the film near‑perfect.

Why This Became A Big Story

These comments blew up quickly in late 2025 because:

  • Many actors, critics, and fans publicly defended Paul Dano, saying his work in There Will Be Blood and films like The Batman shows he is a highly respected character actor.
  • Commentators and fans on social media and forums argued that no director should “go that hard” on a fellow actor in such personal terms, calling Tarantino’s remarks needlessly cruel and disrespectful.

Some discussion also focused on how unusual it is for a high‑profile director to single out a specific performer as a “giant flaw” in a film that is widely considered a modern classic.

TL;DR: Tarantino said the “big giant flaw” of There Will Be Blood is Paul Dano, calling him “weak sauce,” “a weak sister,” and even “the weakest male actor in SAG,” and that the film would rank higher for him if a different actor had played Dano’s role, which sparked major backlash and a wave of support for Dano from fans and colleagues.

Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.