Sophie reportedly said during Samie’s family phone call that Belle’s behaviour was worse than Lucinda’s , and that both Belle and Lucinda were “misbehaving.”

She also supposedly told Samie to stay out of the drama, but when Samie repeated the story to the other girls, she left out the part about Sophie saying Belle was worse than Lucinda.

What Did Sophie Say About Belle on Love Island?

The Key Comment About Belle

From fan forum recaps of the episode, viewers say Sophie told Samie on the call from home that:

  • Belle’s behaviour was “worse” than Lucinda’s.
  • Both Belle and Lucinda were in the wrong, but Belle came off as more serious in Sophie’s eyes.

So the core of it is that Sophie seemed to side more with Lucinda than Belle in that situation, implying Belle crossed the line more.

How Samie Repeated It in the Villa

Fans point out a bit of messiness in how Samie relayed what Sophie said:

  • Sophie: told Samie to stay out of the drama and that Belle’s actions were worse than Lucinda’s.
  • Samie to the girls: reportedly left out the “Belle was worse than Lucinda” part when she recounted the call.

That gap is what kicked off a lot of the forum chatter, because it made Samie look like she was editing the story to soften the blow for Belle or to manage her own position in the drama.

“During a phone conversation with Samie, Sophie advised her to avoid getting involved in the drama and mentioned that Belle's actions were more serious than Lucinda's. However, when Samie shared this information with the other girls, she omitted the latter part…”

How Fans Are Reading It

On discussion threads, people are using this moment to debate:

  • Whether Sophie was being fair in saying Belle was worse than Lucinda.
  • Whether Samie was being sneaky by not repeating Sophie’s full comment.
  • Whether this is another example of Belle being framed as the “villain” and Lucinda as the more sympathetic one this season.

Some commenters feel it shows Sophie quietly backing Lucinda’s side while still trying not to blow things up with Belle through Samie. Others think it mostly exposes Samie’s selective storytelling more than anything Sophie did.

TL;DR

  • Sophie told Samie that Belle’s behaviour was worse than Lucinda’s and that both were out of line.
  • She also told Samie to stay out of the drama.
  • When Samie repeated the conversation, she allegedly skipped the “Belle was worse than Lucinda” part, which is why fans are now dissecting the whole thing online.

Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.