Colts fans are mostly talking about Anthony Richardson Sr., who ended the 2025 season on injured reserve after suffering an orbital fracture near his right eye during a pregame stretching-band mishap and was never activated back to the roster. He is expected to head into 2026 still under contract with Indianapolis but facing an uncertain role behind other quarterbacks on the depth chart.

Quick Scoop

  • The what happened to Colts quarterback discussion right now mainly centers on Anthony Richardson Sr. landing on injured reserve in October 2025 because a resistance band snapped and struck his face, causing an orbital fracture and lingering vision issues.
  • Team doctors and coaches kept him out for the rest of the season due to those vision limitations, even though he had returned to practice and hoped to play in the finale.
  • Richardson has said his eye is improving and that he has “no doubt” he can still reach his NFL potential, but his future in Indianapolis is cloudy because the team has other quarterbacks in the mix and may view him as, at best, a backup going into 2026.
  • Public and forum-style chatter also highlights how a run of freak injuries has derailed his first three seasons, turning a former top-five pick into more of a “what if” story so far, while still leaving a path for a comeback if he can stay healthy.

Many fan and forum comments frame his situation as a mix of bad luck and timing rather than a simple “bust,” noting that his athletic upside remains intriguing if he finally gets a full, healthy season.

What this means right now

  • No major new injury has just happened; the current “latest news” is that Richardson’s 2025 season is officially over, he is rehabbing the eye injury, and the Colts chose not to risk him late in the year.
  • The big offseason storyline will be whether the Colts give him a genuine shot to compete for the starting job in 2026 or explore trade options if they commit to a different long-term starter.

TL;DR: The Colts quarterback people are asking about is Anthony Richardson Sr., whose season ended early after a freak pregame band accident caused an orbital eye fracture, leaving him on injured reserve and creating big questions about his future role with the team.

Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.