In the Hulu series Tell Me Lies , Wrigley’s brother is Drew, and he dies tragically after a series of events tied to guilt, drugs, and an accident that killed a girl named Macy.

Quick Scoop

  • Drew is Wrigley’s younger brother, and he was the one driving the car that accidentally forced Macy off the road, causing the crash that killed her.
  • Crushed by guilt over Macy’s death, Drew spirals mentally, becoming increasingly self-destructive over time.
  • In the timeline of the show, it’s revealed that Drew eventually dies from an accidental overdose after taking painkillers (supplied by Wrigley) and mixing them with alcohol.
  • Wrigley is later shown still grieving hard, blaming himself for both Macy’s death connection and Drew’s overdose, and feeling like he has effectively lost his whole family.

Story Context

  • The fallout begins when an anonymous letter implicates Drew in Macy’s death, leading to him leaving campus and deepening his emotional decline.
  • Seasons 2 and 3 of Tell Me Lies revisit Drew’s death mostly through Wrigley’s trauma, his strained friendships, and how other characters weaponize the letter and the secret around Macy’s accident.

Latest News & Discussion

  • Recent write-ups and recaps (through early 2026) still frame Drew’s death as a pivotal emotional anchor for Wrigley’s character, influencing his behavior, relationships, and his sense of isolation.
  • Fan forums continue to debate who is most to blame—Drew, Wrigley, Lucy, or Stephen—especially around the letter and how that pressure contributed to Drew’s overdose and Wrigley’s ongoing guilt.

TL;DR: Wrigley’s brother Drew caused the car accident that killed Macy, spiraled under the weight of guilt, and ultimately died from an accidental overdose after mixing painkillers and alcohol, leaving Wrigley devastated and haunted by responsibility.

Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.