Edmure Tully survives, but his fate differs a bit between the Game of Thrones TV show and the A Song of Ice and Fire books, and he ends up more “awkward lord in limbo” than dead hero.

Quick Scoop

In both versions, Edmure:

  • Lives through the Red Wedding as a hostage instead of being killed.
  • Is used as a political pawn against his own house and lands.
  • Ends up sidelined rather than gloriously redeemed.

Below I’ll break it down by show vs. books and then touch on what fans and forums have been saying.

In the Game of Thrones TV show

After the Red Wedding

  • Edmure marries Roslin Frey at the Twins and is taken away to the bedding just before the massacre.
  • While Robb and Catelyn are killed, Edmure is thrown in a dungeon and kept as a prisoner by the Freys.

Used as a hostage at Riverrun (Season 6)

  • Years later, the Freys drag Edmure out and use him as leverage during the siege of Riverrun, where his uncle the Blackfish is holding the castle.
  • Under pressure from Jaime Lannister and threats to his wife and child, Edmure orders Riverrun to surrender, betraying the Blackfish and allowing Lannister–Frey forces to retake the castle.
  • Once he does his part, he’s marched back into a cell; the last thing we clearly know is that he’s alive but back in Frey custody.

Missing from the very end

  • Edmure doesn’t appear in Season 7 and was widely discussed as one of the major loose ends.
  • In the show’s final season, he briefly shows up at the council in King’s Landing, where he clumsily puts himself forward as a candidate for the throne and is politely shot down, then sits back down in embarrassment. (This isn’t detailed in the sources above but is the on-screen resolution.)
  • The show never explicitly tells us whether he goes back to Riverrun or what kind of future he has; he simply survives, humiliated but alive, with the implied status of a minor, somewhat ridiculous lord.

So for the TV answer to “what happens to Edmure Tully?”:
He survives the Red Wedding, is kept as a hostage, is forced to surrender Riverrun to save his family, spends years as a prisoner, and finally reappears only to be politically irrelevant and mildly comic at the end.

In the A Song of Ice and Fire books

In the books, Edmure’s fate is similar in outline but less fully resolved, because the series isn’t finished.

Red Wedding and imprisonment

  • Edmure fights for Robb, agrees to marry Roslin Frey in Robb’s stead as part of repairing the Frey alliance, and then is imprisoned when the Red Wedding begins.
  • He’s kept at the Twins as a hostage while Catelyn and Robb are killed and the Freys take over the Riverlands.

The siege of Riverrun

  • Later, the Freys bring Edmure to Riverrun, where the Blackfish is holding out against them. They threaten to hang Edmure in sight of the walls to force a surrender.
  • Jaime Lannister arrives, takes personal control of Edmure as his prisoner, and uses negotiation and intimidation instead of immediate execution.
  • Jaime convinces Edmure to yield the castle: Edmure walks inside, orders the gates opened, and surrenders Riverrun to the Lannisters and Freys.

What’s promised to him

  • Jaime promises that Edmure, Roslin, and their son will be treated with courtesy and allowed to live comfortably, though Edmure will effectively be a political captive, not a free lord ruling his own castle.
  • By the latest book material, Edmure is still alive but in Lannister/Frey-controlled hands, with his ultimate long‑term fate unresolved and heavily debated by fans.

So in the books:
He’s alive, has a child with Roslin Frey, has surrendered Riverrun under pressure, and is being held under honorable but restrictive conditions, with his future left open for later books.

How forums and fans talk about him

Online discussions and fan theories tend to focus on a few themes:

  1. “Dead man walking” speculation
    • Many readers think Edmure is in serious danger long-term, especially because he’s a rival claimant in a region dominated by the Freys and Lannisters and because George R. R. Martin rarely gives gentle, tidy endings.
 * Others argue that precisely because he’s so ordinary and non-heroic, he might limp through the chaos and survive into whatever post-war order emerges.
  1. Moral judgment of his surrender
    • Some fans see his surrender of Riverrun as cowardice or betrayal of the Blackfish.
 * Others defend him, pointing out that he was trying to save his pregnant wife, his child, and the people of Riverrun from a massacre, and that he was outmatched and cornered.
  1. “Wasted potential” in the show
    • Articles and forum threads criticize how the show sidelined him, noting that he’s one of the few surviving Stark/Tully relatives who could have had a meaningful role in the political reshaping of the Riverlands.
 * His final TV appearance, where he awkwardly tries to nominate himself as king, is often cited as turning him into a joke figure, undercutting the tragedy of his story.

Why he matters to the story

Even if he never becomes a major hero, Edmure is still important for a few reasons:

  • He’s the legitimate head of House Tully and a key to any “legal” restoration of the Riverlands once Frey power breaks.
  • His child with Roslin Frey potentially links House Tully and House Frey, which could be either a source of future conflict or a path toward political compromise, depending on how power shifts.
  • As a character, he represents the flawed, ordinary nobility caught between ruthless powers: not brilliant, not monstrous, but trying to do right in a situation with no good options.

Mini SEO-style wrap‑up

  • Main focus keyword: what happens to Edmure Tully
  • Edmure survives the Red Wedding, is used as a hostage to force the surrender of Riverrun, and ends up alive but politically sidelined, both in the show and the books.
  • The latest “news” and forum discussion mostly revolves around whether future books (or any spin‑offs) will restore him to Riverrun or quietly kill him off, with most fans skeptical that he’s headed for a happy ending.

TL;DR: Edmure Tully doesn’t die on screen or on the page (so far); he lives through the Red Wedding, is forced to surrender his home, and ends up as a living but largely powerless pawn whose final fate is still unresolved in the books and only loosely sketched in the show.

Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.