The consignment shop you’re thinking of is almost certainly Plato’s Closet — it’s a well-known chain that often sits right next to (or very near) TJ Maxx in many U.S. shopping plazas, including some areas informally referred to as the “Olive Garden area” due to nearby restaurant clusters.

Why Plato’s Closet fits your description

  • Starts with “P” : ✅ Plato’s Closet
  • Consignment shop : ✅ Specializes in gently used, brand-name clothing and accessories
  • Often next to TJ Maxx : ✅ Frequently co-located in the same strip mall or shopping center
  • “Olive Garden area” : Many TJ Maxx/Plato’s Closet combos are in retail zones that also include Olive Garden, Red Lobster, or similar restaurants — so locals sometimes refer to the whole plaza by the most recognizable anchor (like Olive Garden).

In fact, one Reddit thread from Savannah specifically mentions:

“Clothes Mentor located near TJ Maxx and five blocks below the Toys R Us area.”
But that’s Clothes Mentor , not starting with “P”. For a “P” name, Plato’s Closet is the dominant national brand fitting all your criteria.

Other possibilities (less likely)

While Plato’s Closet is the strongest match, here are a few other “P” consignment shops that could be in your area — though they’re less commonly paired with TJ Maxx:

  • Posh Consignment
  • Premier Consignment
  • Posh Boutique
  • Paradise Consignment

These tend to be local or regional boutiques rather than national chains, so unless you’re in a specific city where one of these is known to neighbor TJ Maxx, Plato’s Closet remains the best bet.

How to confirm quickly

If you want to be 100% sure:

  1. Open Google Maps.
  2. Search: “TJ Maxx near me”.
  3. Look at the neighboring stores — if you see Plato’s Closet , that’s your answer.
  4. Alternatively, search: “consignment shop starting with P near TJ Maxx [your city]”.

Many users have reported finding Plato’s Closet literally adjacent to TJ Maxx in plazas that also include Olive Garden, making it the most probable match for your description.

TL;DR : The shop is very likely Plato’s Closet — a national consignment chain that commonly neighbors TJ Maxx in retail zones that also feature Olive Garden or similar restaurants.

Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.