The lake that may have been the source of some El Dorado legends is Lake Guatavita (spelled “Guatavita,” matching the option “Guativita”).

Direct answer

  • Among the options Titicaca, Michigan, Baikal, and Guativita, the correct choice is Guativita.
  • Ceremonial offerings of gold into Lake Guatavita by the Muisca people helped inspire the El Dorado legend of a golden ruler and hidden treasure.

Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.