Marshals rates higher than Dutton Ranch overall. The reporting available says Marshals beat Dutton Ranch in viewership, with Marshals posting 9.51 million premiere viewers on CBS, while Dutton Ranch drew 2.9 million total viewers on premiere night across its two-episode debut.

What the numbers show

  • Marshals had the stronger total audience on its premiere.
  • Dutton Ranch was still a major launch for Paramount+, setting a record for the platform and reaching 12.9 million global views in its first seven days.
  • If you mean broadcast/cable-style viewership, Marshals clearly comes out ahead.

Simple read

For a straight “which show rates higher?” answer, Marshals is the higher- rated/most-viewed one in the sources available.

tldr

  • Higher overall: Marshals.
  • Strong streaming performance: Dutton Ranch.