In Tell Me Lies , it is revealed that Chris raped Pippa, one of Lucy’s close friends. Pippa does not initially come forward publicly, which is why there is confusion in the story and among viewers.

What happens with Chris and the rape storyline

  • The show establishes that Caitie is the first student who formally accuses Chris of rape, but her case is dismissed by the college due to “lack of evidence” and no other victims speaking up.
  • Later, viewers learn that Pippa was also raped by Chris, but she is too embarrassed and fearful to officially report it or attach her name to the case.
  • There is also mention of at least one additional anonymous victim, implying that Chris has assaulted more than one woman on campus.

Why people think Lucy was the victim

  • Lucy finds out about what Chris did to Pippa and, horrified that no one believes the other victim, impulsively lies and claims that she was raped by Chris, using details from Pippa’s actual assault.
  • This lie spirals: a “Chris is a rapist” social media group ties Lucy and Caitie to the allegations, so many characters on campus think Lucy is a rape victim, even though she was not assaulted by Chris.

The fallout of Lucy’s lie

  • Stephen discovers that Lucy lied about being raped and coerces her into recording a disturbing video confession saying she made it up, weaponizing the situation to control her.
  • Lucy’s decision to lie is framed as morally wrong and deeply harmful, even though it came from a twisted attempt to support Pippa and validate the real victims of Chris.

Bottom note: Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.