In the show Tell Me Lies , Evan cheats on Bree with Lucy Albright.

Quick scoop

  • Evan confesses that he cheated on Bree but initially leaves out who it was with.
  • It is later made explicit that the person he cheated with was Lucy.
  • This revelation adds major tension to Bree’s friendships and drives a lot of the drama in later episodes and recaps.

In the show’s timeline

  • Evan’s cheating happens “last year” in the college timeline before some of the later season events.
  • When he tells Bree he cheated, he does not tell her it was with Lucy, which becomes an emotional landmine for everyone involved.

Why fans talk about it

  • Fans often discuss how Evan still feels tangled up emotionally with Lucy and how that guilt shapes his dynamic with Bree.
  • The cheating is also tied into other love triangles and wedding-day tension in 2015, keeping the topic trending in recent episode recaps and forum threads.

“Evan admits to Stephen that when he cheated on Bree last year, it was with Lucy.”

TL;DR: Evan cheated on Bree with Lucy Albright in Tell Me Lies , and that secret drives a lot of the relationship drama around them.

Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.