Taylor Frankie Paul has never publicly confirmed a specific person by name as the one she “soft‑swung” with, but multiple reports and cast commentary say the couple most directly involved with her and her ex-husband Tate was Miranda and Chase McWhorter, and that she ultimately fell in love with one of the other husbands in that friend group (widely understood to be Chase).

Who Did Taylor Frankie Paul Swing With?

The question “who did Taylor Frankie Paul swing with” comes from the viral “soft-swinging” scandal that exploded out of the Utah MomTok community in 2022 and has since resurfaced thanks to reality TV and online forum debates.

Quick Scoop on the Scandal

  • Taylor and her then-husband Tate Paul were part of a group of married friends experimenting with “soft swinging” (intimate acts with others but with boundaries like “not going all the way”).
  • Taylor later admitted she broke those rules and “stepped out” of the agreement by becoming emotionally and physically involved with another husband in the group.
  • When she publicly confessed this on TikTok Live in mid‑2022, it led to her divorce and blew up into a full‑on internet scandal.

In her own words, Taylor has said she “fell in love with one of the other husbands” in the swinging circle, crossing the line they had set.

So… Who Was Involved?

From public reporting, reality‑show commentary, and later interviews:

  • The core couple repeatedly named in connection with Taylor and Tate is Miranda and Chase McWhorter.
  • A castmate on The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives flat‑out says Miranda and her ex-husband Chase were “heavily involved in the swinging scandal with Taylor and her ex-husband.”
  • Coverage of the resurfaced drama notes that Gibbons (Miranda, by her married name at the time) alleged that Taylor and her ex-husband had sex and fell in love after she said they were done swinging.

However:

  • Taylor herself has carefully avoided giving a full public “name list,” saying she’s tried to respect others’ privacy and hasn’t told “the whole story” yet.
  • Some outlets and forums treat the “who exactly” question as partly speculative, piecing details together from her lives, podcasts, and the Hulu show.

In other words, the most widely reported answer is that Taylor and Tate were swinging within a small MomTok friend group and that the key couple involved was Miranda and Chase McWhorter, with Taylor ultimately crossing boundaries with Chase.

How the “Soft-Swinging” Worked

To understand the context of who she swung with, it helps to know the rules they said they had:

  • Taylor described “soft swinging” as doing intimate things like making out or sexual activity without going “all the way.”
  • She and Tate agreed:
    • No disappearing “behind closed doors.”
* No full intercourse with others.
  • On a podcast and later on TV, she claimed the group sometimes had sex in the same room or even the same bed with their spouses present, treating it like a shared experience, not secret affairs.

The scandal really erupted because she says she broke those rules by having sex with another husband separately and developing feelings, something other women in the group have backed up in their own accounts.

What People Are Saying Online (Forums & 2024–2025 Buzz)

On Reddit threads and other forums:

  • Fans dissect timelines of TikToks, podcast clips, and episodes of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives to match names, hints, and dialogue.
  • Many posters argue that Taylor is the only one who openly admits to swinging , while others try to distance themselves now that it’s on TV.
  • A recurring theme in discussions is whether former friends like Miranda tried to “deny everything” publicly, leaving Taylor to look like the sole villain while they moved on quietly.

Because Taylor has suggested she might one day tell the full story from her perspective, people still treat the scandal as an ongoing mystery rather than a fully closed case.

Mini Timeline of Key Moments

  1. Pre‑2022 – Taylor, Tate, and a small MomTok circle allegedly start experimenting with “soft swinging.”
  1. June 2022 – Taylor’s TikTok Live confession: she reveals the soft-swinging arrangement, admits breaking the rules, and announces her divorce.
  1. 2023–2024 – She talks more about the scandal in interviews and podcast appearances, confirming an emotional affair with another husband.
  1. 2024–2025 – The story is dramatized and rehashed on The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives and in profiles as she moves into reality‑TV fame and, later, a Bachelorette role.

Bottom Line

If you’re searching “who did Taylor Frankie Paul swing with,” the clearest public answer is:

  • She and her ex-husband Tate were in a soft-swinging agreement with a small group of married friends.
  • The couple identified in reporting and on the show as heavily involved with them is Miranda and Chase McWhorter.
  • Taylor has said she went beyond the rules and fell in love with one of the other husbands in that circle, widely understood to be Chase, but she has not sat down and fully, formally named every person involved from her side.

Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.