Right now, neither the Rangers nor the Islanders looks like a sure playoff bet for 2027 , but the Rangers appear to have the better shot on current offseason outlooks. Recent 2027 Stanley Cup odds list the New York Islanders at +8000 , which is a long shot, while other New York-area teams are also outside the top tier.

What the latest signals say

  • The Islanders are being talked about as a team trying to build toward a playoff run in 2027 , which suggests they are not yet viewed as a lock.
  • The current odds snapshot puts the Islanders near the bottom of the contender list, which points to a low playoff probability compared with stronger teams.
  • A recent note also said the Rangers and Islanders both missed the playoffs in 2026, showing neither team is coming from a strong immediate position.

Simple read

  • More likely: Rangers
  • Less likely: Islanders

That is still only a best guess , because playoff qualification can change a lot with offseason moves, injuries, and goaltending. If you want the sharpest answer, I can turn this into a quick Rangers-vs-Islanders playoff outlook table.