Googly Eyes on The Masked Singer was revealed to be MLB legend David "Big Papi" Ortiz during the Season 14 premiere on January 7, 2026.

The fuzzy red monster costume, complete with wriggling tentacles and oversized eyeballs, matched Ortiz's larger-than-life personality—he even joked it was a solid workout, skipping the gym for a month. Ortiz, a Boston Red Sox icon with a record for multihomer games, performed "Turn Down For What" but was eliminated first after losing to Cat Witch and a second-round vote.

Key Clues and Panel Guesses

Googly Eyes' package hinted at leadership, monster hits, and confidence , sparking wild theories before the unmasking.

  • Panel locked in athlete guesses, tying into Ortiz's baseball legacy.
  • Fans on Reddit buzzed about the "unhinged energy" from the premiere performance.

"Being an athlete is to be able to show that we're so much more than just athletes." – Googly Eyes' clue vibe, later tied to Ortiz.

Why It Fits Big Papi

Ortiz retired in 2016 as a home run king from the Dominican Republic, bringing clutch charisma to the stage—much like his World Series heroics. The reveal shocked but delighted, with FOX calling it an "exciting" kickoff amid 10 debuting costumes like Pangolin and Queen Corgi.

Trending Fan Chatter

Forums lit up post-premiere:

  • Reddit r/TheMaskedSinger : 19+ votes on Googly Eyes' chaotic debut, loving the "pure monster madness."
  • Early costume teases from December 2025 built hype.
  • Viewers noted his shouting style prioritized fun over vocals, perfect for lighthearted celeb gossip.

Season 14 airs Wednesdays on FOX (stream on Hulu), with Ortiz already a fan- favorite memory as of January 8, 2026.

TL;DR : Googly Eyes is David Ortiz—Big Papi brought baseball swagger to The Masked Singer before a quick exit.

Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.