Tobey Maguire is not publicly confirmed to be dating anyone right now; as of early 2026, he is widely reported as single, despite new Super Bowl romance rumors.

Quick Scoop: who is Tobey Maguire dating?

Current status (early 2026)

Most reputable entertainment outlets say Tobey Maguire is currently single , with no confirmed girlfriend or partner.

Recent coverage explicitly notes that, as of early 2026, there is “no confirmed romantic relationship” attached to him.

So if you’re asking “who is Tobey Maguire dating?” the only accurate answer right now is: there’s no verified, on-the-record partner.

Why everyone is talking about Mishka Silva

The latest wave of online buzz comes from Super Bowl LX in February 2026, where Tobey was photographed and filmed in a VIP suite with 20‑year‑old influencer and model Mishka Silva.

They were seen chatting closely, sitting side by side, and at one point she relaxed with her leg stretched toward him while smiling and playing with her hair, which many viewers read as flirty.

Entertainment sites describe this as “sparking dating rumors” and a “flirt‑fest,” not as a confirmed relationship.

Crucially, coverage also notes there was no obvious PDA during the game, and neither of them has made any public comment about dating each other.

In other words, Mishka Silva is the face of the latest rumor cycle, but there is no official confirmation they’re a couple.

Fact‑check vs. viral gossip

Online, a lot of posts claim things like “Tobey Maguire has a 20‑year‑old girlfriend” or that he’s “found a new Mary Jane.”

A dedicated fact‑check thread breaks this down and labels the idea that he is definitively dating a 20‑year‑old as “mostly false” right now.

Key points from that fact‑check:

  • The age‑gap narrative is recycled from earlier 2024 rumors linking him to model/actress Lily Chee.
  • Those older rumors never became a confirmed relationship story, and more recent updates describe Tobey as single in early 2026.
  • The new viral claim that he is dating a 20‑year‑old is treated as gossip with no hard proof.

So while YouTube commentators and social posts talk as if the relationship is real, more cautious outlets stop at “rumored” or “speculated.”

Recent dating history (very short recap)

Before this latest Super Bowl moment, reporting on his personal life has mostly focused on:

  • His past marriage to jewelry designer Jennifer Meyer (married 2007, separated 2016, divorce finalized 2020), with whom he shares two children.
  • A post‑divorce relationship with model Tatiana Dieteman that lasted several years and reportedly ended in 2022.
  • Later speculative links, such as rumors involving Lily Chee around 2024, which never solidified into an officially acknowledged relationship.

Recent entertainment write‑ups now sum this up by saying that, after these relationships, he is “reported to be single” going into 2026.

Forums, speculation, and what’s actually known

Pop culture forums and comment sections are having big debates over:

  • The large age gap (50 vs. 20) in the Mishka Silva rumors.
  • Whether sitting closely and chatting at a high‑profile event is enough to call someone a “girlfriend.”
  • Whether this is just another example of celebrity gossip running ahead of facts.

But zooming out:

  • There is evidence they were together at the Super Bowl in a VIP suite and appeared friendly.
  • There is no evidence in the form of statements, repeated couple‑style appearances, or reps confirming a relationship.

So the safest way to phrase it is:

  • He has sparked dating rumors with Mishka Silva after their Super Bowl appearance.
  • As of now, credible reports still list Tobey Maguire as single with no confirmed girlfriend.

Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.