Fox News has not officially announced a single permanent replacement for Judge Jeanine Pirro on “The Five” yet. Instead, they are using a rotating cast of co-hosts in her former seat while they decide on a long‑term choice.

What’s Confirmed So Far

  • Judge Jeanine Pirro left “The Five” in May 2025 after being tapped by President Donald Trump to serve as interim U.S. Attorney for Washington, D.C.
  • Fox News stated that a rotation of network personalities will fill her chair on “The Five” until a new co-host is named.
  • As of the latest reports, no permanent successor has been publicly confirmed by Fox News.

Names Being Talked About

Various media blogs, fan sites, and YouTube commentators have floated possible successors, but these are speculation , not official Fox announcements.

Commonly mentioned types of candidates include:

  • High-profile conservative female attorneys or legal analysts (to mirror Pirro’s legal background).
  • Established Fox News hosts who already guest-host or appear frequently on opinion panels.
  • Personalities with a strong pro-Trump or populist brand who could match Pirro’s combative on‑air style.

Some fan and commentary pieces even single out specific lawyers and pundits as “ideal” or “likely” replacements, but they clearly frame these as predictions or wish lists rather than inside confirmations.

What Fox Is Likely Looking For

Coverage about Fox’s internal process and audience expectations suggests a few key traits matter for whoever ultimately lands the seat:

  • Legal expertise or at least strong policy chops, to keep that tough “prosecutor” vibe.
  • A solid conservative voice that resonates with Fox’s core prime‑time audience.
  • Charisma, quick debating skills, and chemistry with the existing panel.

A survey cited in one article notes that viewers especially value legal expertise, a strong conservative perspective, and on‑screen presence in a replacement host.

Forum / Fan Discussion Flavor

Many fan discussions and click‑driven articles frame the topic almost like a casting rumor thread, with people asking:

“Who can possibly fill Judge Jeanine’s shoes on The Five?”

These pieces tend to:

  1. Recount Pirro’s impact on the show and her fiery style.
  2. List several potential Fox figures or conservative media personalities.
  3. Invite readers or viewers to weigh in on who they’d like to see.

They consistently acknowledge that Fox has not yet named a permanent replacement , so all lists and “inside scoop” headlines remain speculative at this point.

Bottom line: If you’re searching “who will replace Judge Jeanine Pirro on The Five,” the most accurate answer right now is that Fox News is still rotating co-hosts and has not announced a permanent replacement yet; everything else is rumor or fan speculation.

Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.