Right now, there are two different situations with Prue and Bake Off, which is why things look a bit confusing.

Short answer

  • For the main Great British Bake Off series :
    As of the latest public updates, a permanent replacement for Prue Leith has not yet been officially announced. Channel 4 has said a new judge “will be revealed in due time”, but no confirmed name has been released.
  • For Great Celebrity Bake Off / Stand Up To Cancer specials :
    Caroline Waldegrave OBE has already stepped in to replace Prue on the celebrity Stand Up To Cancer specials , judging alongside Paul Hollywood.

So if the question is “who will replace Prue on Bake Off?” the only definite answer so far is Caroline Waldegrave for the celebrity charity specials , while the full‑time main‑series replacement has not yet been officially confirmed.

What’s officially confirmed

  • Prue Leith has:
    • Stepped back from specials like Stand Up To Cancer.
* Now announced she is **leaving Bake Off completely** , after nearly a decade as a judge.
  • Channel 4 / Love Productions have:
    • Confirmed Bake Off will continue with Paul Hollywood, Noel Fielding and Alison Hammond.
* Stated that a **new judge will be announced later** , without naming who it will be.

This means there is no officially named successor yet for the main tent.

Caroline Waldegrave’s role

  • For Great Celebrity Bake Off for Stand Up To Cancer (2025 specials) :
    • Prue’s long‑time friend and colleague , chef Caroline Waldegrave OBE , has been confirmed as her replacement on the judging panel.
* She appears **alongside Paul Hollywood** to judge the celebrity bakers.

So:

  • If you’re hearing “Prue has been replaced”, that refers to the charity/celebrity specials , where the replacement is known: Caroline Waldegrave.
  • For the main autumn series , the show has only said that a new judge is coming , not who.

Speculation and betting talk

Because no main‑series replacement has been formally revealed, UK entertainment and betting coverage is speculating on who might get the job.

  • Articles mention:
    • A “shortlist” and “contenders” to step into Prue’s shoes , including some big‑name food personalities and Bake Off‑connected figures.
* Bookmakers installing **Caroline Waldegrave as an early favourite** to take the full‑time spot, alongside other names like Nigella Lawson and various Bake Off alumni, but **none of that is confirmed casting** , just odds and chatter.

Those pieces are rumour/odds , not official announcements from Channel 4 or Love Productions.

Forum & fan discussion vibe

On forums and social media, fans are:

  • Sad to lose Prue , who many feel “brings so much to the tent” and has a comparable level of expertise to Mary Berry.
  • Split between:
    • Wanting another big‑name TV cook (like Nigella‑type figures mentioned in speculation).
* Hoping for a **past winner or long‑time Bake Off baker** to keep the show’s “baker‑to‑judge” heart.

But for now, it’s all wish‑lists and predictions , not confirmed casting.

Bottom line

  • Celebrity / Stand Up To Cancer specials :
    Prue’s replacement is Caroline Waldegrave OBE , and that’s official.
  • Main Great British Bake Off series :
    Prue has announced her exit , and the show has confirmed a new judge is coming , but no name has been officially revealed yet.

Information gathered from public forums or data available on the internet and portrayed here.