Tom Holland’s Spider-Man is generally considered the strongest of the three, especially when you look at overall feats, agility, and what he handles by the end of No Way Home.

Quick Scoop

  • Tom Holland : strongest overall, with the best mix of power, speed, and durability.
  • Tobey Maguire : most iconic raw strength moments, like the train scene, but usually ranked just behind Tom overall.
  • Andrew Garfield : very strong and agile, but most rankings place him third of the three.

Why Tom usually wins

Tom’s version gets the edge because he has the most consistent high-end feats across multiple films, and his fights show strong improvisation plus advanced combat skill for his age. He also benefits from more tech and a broader range of battles, which makes him the most complete version of Spider-Man in many fan and critic discussions.

How the others compare

Tobey often looks like the physically toughest in single moments, especially in older, more dramatic strength scenes, which is why many fans still argue for him. Andrew is fast, acrobatic, and intense, but most comparisons still put him behind Tobey and Tom in overall strength ranking.

Simple ranking

  1. Tom Holland
  2. Tobey Maguire
  3. Andrew Garfield

TL;DR: Tom Holland is usually ranked strongest overall, Tobey is the best “raw strength” argument, and Andrew comes third.